Kevin Reddington’s televised appeal follows a mistrial, but presidential clemency does not cover the Massachusetts charges against his client.
Lindsay Clancy’s attorney brought a request for presidential intervention to national television on Tuesday, but the request runs into a basic constitutional limit: Donald Trump cannot pardon Massachusetts state offenses.
Kevin Reddington appealed to Trump during a September 8 interview on Good Morning America, asking him to consider a pardon for Clancy. ABC reported that Reddington also expressed hope for an agreement between the defense and prosecutors.
Clancy pleaded not guilty to three murder charges arising from the January 2023 deaths of her children, Cora, Dawson and Callan, in Duxbury, Massachusetts. Her trial ended in a mistrial on September 4 after jurors failed to reach a verdict. The mistrial was not an acquittal or a conviction.
The distinction between a public appeal and an available legal remedy matters here. The Justice Department explains that presidential clemency does not extend to state criminal offenses. Congress’s Constitution Annotated likewise identifies federal, rather than state, crimes as the scope of the presidential pardon power.
Whatever political attention Reddington’s request attracts, a presidential pardon cannot dispose of these Massachusetts charges. Readers should not mistake the prominence of the person being addressed for authority over the case.
The deaths of three children deserve sustained attention, including careful reporting on the defense, the prosecution and whatever proceedings follow. A television interview changes none of the obligations to establish criminal responsibility through the applicable legal process.
The useful questions now concern developments in Massachusetts: whether the parties reach an agreement, what prosecutors announce and what the court orders. Those answers matter more than speculation about a White House action that cannot resolve the state case.
Sources: ABC News: https://abcnews.com/GMA/News/lindsay-clancys-attorney-kevin-reddington-asks-trump-pardon/story?id=136258585 U.S. Department of Justice: https://www.justice.gov/pardon/frequently-asked-questions Congress, Constitution Annotated: https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/artII-S2-C1-3-5/ALDE_00013322/
Claire Whitmore is a conservative writer covering culture, family, education, media, and the rapidly changing expectations placed on women in modern America. Her work examines the intersection between politics and everyday life, particularly debates surrounding motherhood, relationships, career expectations, schools, and popular culture. Whitmore is skeptical of political movements that treat traditional choices as inherently outdated and argues that genuine freedom requires allowing women to define success for themselves. At The Dispatch Room, she brings a measured but unapologetically conservative perspective to some of the country’s most contentious cultural debates.
Discussion
Loading discussion…